Case Report – Defendant can maintain privilege against third party it sues for spoliation

24 Mar

On March 12th, the Ontario Superior Court of Justice held that a defendant to a negligence claim could claim privilege in certain records against a third-party that it sued for destroying evidence related to its defence.

The matter arose out of a building fire. The owner sued a roofing contractor, who obtained several reports from a company hired to conduct an origin and cause investigation. It claimed litigation privilege in the reports in the main action. The roofing contractor later brought a third-party claim against the owner’s investigator, alleging that the investigator negligently destroyed evidence and prejudiced its defence. The third-party brought a motion to compel the roofing contractor to produce the investigation reports over which it had claimed privilege in the main action.

The Court held that the spoliation action was independent from the main action but that it was sufficiently related to the main action for privilege to apply across both actions.  It said:

In the case at bar, the pivotal issue in both the main action and the third party action is whether or not the parties have been able to identify the source area and the cause of the fire.  In the main action the plaintiffs must prove that the defendants’ use of the heating torch while effecting roof repairs was the cause of the fire.  The third party claim is a related action the success of which depends upon the defendants proving that the third parties negligently inhibited their ability to identify the source area and cause of the same fire, and thus be able to effectively defend against the plaintiff’s claim. 

The Court also dismissed an argument that the defendant waived privilege by disclosing one of the reports subject to its privilege claim. It held that the plaintiff had not met its burden of proving an implied waiver.

Rudolph Meyer & Son Ltd. (c.o.b. Meyer’s County Sausage) v. Endurowe Consulting, 2009 CanLII 10400 (ON S.C.).

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: