On September 28th, the Information and Privacy Commissioner/Ontario affirmed a $140,132 fee estimate and decision to deny a request to waive the same.
The requester was interested in matters related to the expenditure of funds on a new hospital site in Windsor. In relation to this interest, he sought hospital e-mails from 17 accounts that spanned a nine year period. The requester provided 100 search terms that were broad and seemingly un-targeted at the subject matter of interest.
The hospital generated its estimate based on an application of the requester’s terms. It estimated 145,000 pages of responsive records and calculated the estimate based on the (standard) two minutes of preparation time per page. It did not include time for its search.
The IPC upheld the fee estimate and the fee waiver denial. It said, “a fee waiver would shift an unreasonable burden of the cost to hospital.”
I’ve been tracking “e-FOI” decisions for many years, and believe this to be the highest estimate the IPC has affirmed. In general, and thankfully, the IPC has been pragmatic in handling fee, fee estimate and fee waiver appeals. This is important given how expensive it can be to process e-mail requests and because the law ought to encourage requesters to work with institutions to tailor their requests.